The potential link between nose picking and an elevated risk of contracting COVID has recently been explored in a study conducted among health workers. This article delves into the study’s findings and raises important questions about hand hygiene, the study’s implications for the general population, and the need for cautious interpretation.
Study Overview
The study tracked 219 Dutch health workers, employing regular antibody testing and self-reported COVID test results. These participants were later questioned about their nose picking habits, exposure to symptomatic colleagues, and contacts outside of work.
Higher Risk among Nose Pickers
Results revealed that slightly over 17% of health workers who reported nose picking contracted COVID, compared to about 6% of non-nose pickers. This association might be explained by the fact that COVID infection hinges on the virus contacting the mucous membranes of the respiratory system, including those in the nose.
Fomite Transmission and Risk
The theory is that if a person touches a contaminated surface and then puts their finger in their nose, they could be exposed to the virus. However, the risk of such transmission is relatively low, with the United States Centres for Disease Control estimating a 1 in 10,000 chance of infection from a contaminated surface.
Curious Anomalies
Oddly, the study revealed that individuals who picked their noses only monthly had a higher infection rate than daily nose pickers. This counterintuitive finding contradicts the expectation that more frequent nose picking would increase the risk due to increased transmission opportunities.
Study Design Considerations
The study’s design could potentially introduce biases. Just over half of the approached participants chose to take part, leading to possible selection bias. Additionally, the study’s reliance on self-reported behaviors and exposure could be influenced by social desirability bias and recall errors.
Complex Factors at Play
The study did not adequately control for gender, which is crucial as hand hygiene and behaviors like nose picking can differ among genders. As such, it’s challenging to definitively conclude whether nose picking directly correlates with the heightened risk of COVID.
Cautious Interpretation and Hygiene Practices
In light of these limitations, the study’s conclusions might be overstated. While the risk of SARS-CoV-2 transmission through nose picking appears relatively low, maintaining proper hand hygiene and using tissues for nose-related activities can mitigate any potential risk. It’s also important to prioritize preventing airborne transmission by wearing masks, especially in crowded or poorly ventilated spaces.
While the study introduces an intriguing idea of nose picking potentially influencing COVID risk, its findings should be approached with caution due to the complexities of human behavior and the limitations of the study design. Public health recommendations should continue to emphasize comprehensive preventive measures, including proper hand hygiene, mask-wearing, and ensuring well-ventilated spaces.
For more updates stay tuned to FELA News!
Image: CDC
